Aesthetic education between judgment and experience: Dewey in the radical aesthetic
April 2025
|
Journal article
|
Genre
This essay analyzes Isobel Armstrong's use of John Dewey's aesthetic theory in The Radical Aesthetic (2000), paying particular attention to how she stages a confrontation between Dewey and John Guillory. I argue that Armstrong's admirable emphasis on experience leads her to overreach in her opposition to judgment and to fumble the question of how traditional art practices (like poetry) might contribute to a democratized aesthetic education.
Criticism and our modes of abstraction
March 2025
|
Journal article
|
New Literary History
This essay argues that any adequate account of literary studies as an intellectual
discipline has to reckon with the aesthetic nature of literary works. To make my case, I draw on
the philosophy of John Dewey and Alfred North Whitehead, the aesthetics of Susanne K.
Langer, and accounts of criticism by Louise Rosenblatt and Kenneth Burke, all of whom I show
to be indebted to William James. Key to my argument is their redefinition of knowledge in terms
of “modes of abstraction” and their elaboration of concepts geared towards registering the
distinctive kinds of abstractive thinking at work in criticism and the arts.
Reality in America, redux: on Trump panic fiction
November 2024
|
Journal article
|
American Literary History
This essay explains why the election of Donald Trump in 2016 marks a literary historical event. In particular, I show how the liberal response to Trump, as well as Trump’s own persona, foregrounded an unsettling confusion between fiction and reality that led novelists to question the value of their craft. Focusing on a subset of what I call “Trump panic fiction”—novels that dramatize Trump’s election in the key of ontological alarm—I argue that literary depictions of Trump double as meditations on the relation between the evocative powers of art and the explanatory power of facts. To make sense of these meditations, I situate Trump panic fictions by Hari Kunzru, Ben Lerner, Lauren Oyler, Patricia Lockwood, and Ayad Akhtar within a longer history of US writers puzzling over the relation between writing and the real, a history that gained a new inflection when the critical acclaim of autofiction coincided with Trump’s “post-truth” presidency. Looking back to Lionel Trilling’s essay “Reality in America,” I claim that novelistic portrayals of Trump struggle to reinvent the liberal aesthetic for our current political moment.
Back to the classroom: what Whitehead took from art, and what a new aesthetic paradigm can take from Whitehead
April 2024
|
Chapter
|
More-Than-Human Aesthetics: Venturing Beyond the Bifurcation of Nature
This chapter argues that a new aesthetic paradigm requires a new paradigm of aesthetic education. I elaborate what this paradigm looks like in Whitehead’s work, starting with his educational writing and moving through his meditations on abstractions and ‘aesthetic significance’ in Modes of Thought (1968, first published 1938). Throughout, I show how Whitehead turned to aesthetics to combat what he saw as the primary intellectual evil of his age: the problem of disciplinary specialization, which he regarded as the institutional manifestation of the modern habit of letting nature bifurcate. Arguably, this problem is with us more than ever, with the added danger that many disciplines – those that fall short on research-based metrics – are in the process of being cut from the university entirely. Whitehead’s notion of aesthetic education, framed to address this threat but made ever harder to grasp because of it, forces us to ask: how can we justify and institute modes of thought that fall outside the ‘knowledge factory’ model of the modern research university?
How blue is read: language and sensation in literature and philosophy
December 2023
|
Journal article
|
Philosophy and Literature
Philosophers and art critics have long argued that the language of color misses or even mars the ineffable sensation of color. But a literary perspective shows otherwise. Starting with examples of colors read but not seen, and then discussing how philosophers have addressed (and often muddled) the so-called problem of color, I propose thinking of color terms as techniques for stabilizing and directing color sensations. I then show how William H. Gass and Maggie Nelson develop a version of this idea in their respective books about blue, which are really books about the relationship between writing and quality.
Aesthetic education without guarantees: an introduction
March 2023
|
Journal article
|
PMLA
Rorty against Rorty: climate change, rug-pulling, and the rhetoric of philosophy
September 2022
|
Journal article
|
Common Knowledge
As the leading contribution to the Common Knowledge symposium “Whatever Happened to Richard Rorty?,” this essay asks why Rorty was so often taken to be saying things that he claimed he was not. The argument is that Rorty’s rhetorical approach and jargon engendered this confusion and undermined his effectiveness as a philosopher and public intellectual. The focus here is on two points: first, on how, in his eagerness to shut down attempts to claim a privileged path to Reality, he gave the impression of dismissing not only hierarchies but also distinctions; and second, on how his separation of causes and reasons retained a dualism of the “one world, many perspectives” model that elsewhere he rejected. This essay concludes that leading figures of science studies at the present time, notably Bruno Latour, Isabelle Stengers, and Donna Haraway, better equip readers to move past the feeling of deprivation that comes from shedding centuries- old philosophical assumptions and that their explicit rejection of the nature/culture binary makes their work better suited to addressing the great problem of our time — climate change.
Most of us experience the real world as colorful. Apples are red or green; the sky is blue or grey; your shirt is white or striped. The mundane objects of our lives come to us with and through their colors. It comes as a surprise, then, that realism – the literary style credited with having a fidelity to the real world – should be so lacking in colors, at least compared to its counterparts at the turn of the twentieth century. Scan the works of Henry James and Edith Wharton for color terms, and you’ll get the occasional description of an outfit, a room, a landscape. But these won’t be dwelt upon. This is due in part to the fact that the reality that realism commits itself to describing is, at heart, social reality rather than physical or even perceptual reality. If you search James and Wharton for “color” itself, you’ll mostly turn up instances of that preeminently social use of the term: Winterbourne “colors” when Daisy Miller bluntly invokes her “reputation”; Lily Bart’s “color deepens” when Selden suggests she come up to his room at The Bendick. And so on.
How to read color: writing, wallpaper, and the case of Charlotte Perkins Gilman
January 2020
|
Journal article
|
Word & Image
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 3602 Creative and Professional Writing, 4705 Literary Studies, 36 Creative Arts and Writing, 3 Good Health and Well Being
Chromographia American Literature and the Modernization of Color
January 2019
|
Book
The first major literary and cultural history of color in America, 1880-1930 Chromographia tells the story of how color became modern and how literature, by engaging with modern color, became modernist.
Literary Criticism
Learning to See with Milton Bradley
January 2017
|
Chapter
|
Bright Modernity
The Articulate Eye: Color-Music, the Color Sense, and the Language of Abstraction
January 2017
|
Journal article
|
Configurations
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 4702 Cultural Studies, 4705 Literary Studies
Of Primitives and Primaries
July 2016
|
Journal article
|
Cabinet
The Close and the Concrete: Aesthetic Formalism in Context
January 2016
|
Journal article
|
New Literary History
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 4705 Literary Studies
The Habit of Art: Whitehead, Aesthetics, and Pragmatism.
April 2015
|
Chapter
|
Thinking with Whitehead and the American Pragmatists Experience and Reality
Philosophy
The Lure of Whitehead
October 2014
|
Edited book
Once largely ignored, the speculative philosophy of Alfred North Whitehead has assumed a new prominence in contemporary theory across the humanities and social sciences. Philosophers and artists, literary critics and social theorists, anthropologists and computer scientists have all embraced Whitehead's thought, extending it through inquiries into the nature of life, the problem of consciousness, and the ontology of objects, as well as into experiments in education and digital media.The Lure of Whitehead offers readers not only a comprehensive introduction to Whitehead's philosophy but also a demonstration of how his work advances our emerging understanding of life in the posthuman epoch. Contributors: Jeffrey A. Bell, Southeastern Louisiana U; Nathan Brown, U of California, Davis; Peter Canning; Didier Debaise, Free U of Brussels; Roland Faber, Claremont Lincoln U; Michael Halewood, U of Essex; Graham Harman, American U in Cairo; Bruno Latour, Sciences Po Paris; Erin Manning, Concordia U, Montreal; Steven Meyer, Washington U; Luciana Parisi, U of London; Keith Robinson, U of Arkansas at Little Rock; Isabelle Stengers, Free U of Brussels; James Williams, U of Dundee.
What Difference Can Pragmatism Make for Literary Study?
April 2012
|
Journal article
|
American Literary History
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 4705 Literary Studies
Red Cars with Red Lights and Red Drivers: Color, Crane, and Qualia
December 2009
|
Journal article
|
American Literature
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 4705 Literary Studies
Experience and Signs: Towards a Pragmatist Literary Criticism
December 2008
|
Journal article
|
New Literary History
47 Language, Communication and Culture, 4705 Literary Studies